Her audition: Beth Griffith-Manley, 46, of Detroit, Mich., auditioned with “Until You Come Back to Me” by Aretha Franklin. Midway through the performance, she earned chair turns from John Legend and Kelly Clarkson. Kelly complimented her effortless performance and the fact that she nailed an Aretha Franklin song. Noting the similarity of the rasp in their voices, Beth picked Team Kelly.

READ MORE